“Public value describes the value that an organization or activity contributes to society.” Wikipedia
“One cannot be pessimistic about the West. This is the native home of hope. When it fully learns that cooperation, not rugged individualism, is the quality that most characterizes and preserves it, then it will have achieved itself and outlived its origins. Then it has a chance to create a society to match its scenery.” Wallace Stegner, The Sound of Mountain Water
Introduction
We surveyed library Return on Investment (ROI) studies in last month’s Your Library Matters, exploring ROI as a means of evaluating and promoting libraries’ public value. ROI measures profitability and cost-efficiency, which are tangible economic benefits. Most library benefits are intangible*, and many are social values instead of economic values, which makes ROI an imperfect measure for libraries.
This essay first explores public, library-adjacent intangible values, and then proposes using Social Return on Investment (SROI) as a planning and evaluation tool for identifying and evaluating libraries’ impact upon their users and communities. Additionally, this essay extolls the effectiveness of partnering with other organizations engaged in delivering public value.
* According to Merriam-Webster: “…something that cannot be physically touched, seen, or sensed, yet still exists, holds meaning, or has value.”
’Value’ means different things
In an October 2026 e-mail exchange with Dr. Greg Gilpin, a Montana State University economist who with Ezra Karger and Peter Nencka published a 2023 study titled The Returns to Public Library Investment, Dr. Gilpin wrote [my parentheses]:
“From an economist’s perspective, I would distinguish between [a] value that is difficult to measure and [b] value that falls outside a particular ROI calculation. Some broader benefits can be studied, [e.g.] even if assigning them a credible dollar value is difficult. An ROI estimate can contribute to the discussion, but its usefulness depends on being clear about what it captures, what it leaves out, and the assumptions behind it.”
In economics, value is a measure of the benefit provided by a good or service to a buyer. These are often tangible values, things that you can see, touch, or measure. Like a loaf of bread or a trip to Spain. They can also be intangible, like a customer’s loyalty or good will.
In philosophy, the word ‘value’ is (to me) a fathomless rabbit hole, but in the interest of brevity, we can think of value as “the worth, usefulness, or merit of something.” Things are valuable if they themselves are good, or if they lead to good things, things like pleasure, satisfaction, virtue, health, freedom, or knowledge. These examples are all intangible.
A 2013 Pew Research Report suggested that Americans value libraries for reasons that (except for the first) turn out to be largely intangible:
Providing materials and resources
Giving everyone a chance to succeed
Promoting literacy and the love of reading
Improving their community’s quality of life
Providing otherwise hard-to-find community services
More generally, but germane to this discussion, a 2025 Gallup survey asked more than 2,000 Americans which of twenty-five values they thought were most important in their lives. Gallup’s responses that receiving double-digit scores were:
Family, 49%
Freedom, 30%
Health, 27%
Integrity, 27%
Faith, 26%
Trustworthiness, 20%
Happiness, 17%
Respect, 17%
Kindness, 14%
Knowledge, 12%
(Top ten results; online results are more detailed and nuanced.)
Common sense suggests libraries review their library’s value proposition in light of both the Pew and the Gallup lists of community values. ‘Value proposition’ is (simplified) the economic value a seller delivers to their customers.
Public Value
One generally respected concept of ‘public value’ can be traced Mark H. Moore’s 1995 book, Creating Public Value – Strategic Management in Government. Moore is the Harvard Kennedy School, Professor of Strategic Management. (This title is available in print, or as a copy linked from Ragged University, or as a Kindle edition from Amazon, or used.)
Moore explores the concept of public value, illustrating through a number of real-life examples how the outcomes or impacts experienced by an organization’s users and community are useful measures of management’s performance, and by extension, serves to evaluate the public institution the managers are managing.
Libraries address their users’ and community’s library-related needs, subject to the constraints of time, money, and staff capacity. It’s impossible for any library, working alone, to do all that’s needed. Often libraries work alongside other public entities who likewise are striving to create public value. As Dr. Gilpin wrote in our October e-mail exchange, “Libraries can create value by helping other organizations reach people, coordinate services, and accomplish things they could not accomplish as effectively on their own.”
Social Return on Investment (SROI)
Around the year 2000, the financial concept of ROI was extended by the invention of an evaluation tool called Social Return on Investment (SROI). SROI is designed to measure publicly valued impacts beyond profitability or fiscal efficiency. A 2019 British Columbia Library Association report, written by Vancouver (BC) Public Library’s Greg McLeod, described SROI as follows:
“The idea of SROI fits into the major trend of evaluation and assessment in public libraries: moving away from counting outputs (books lent, program attendance) and toward outcomes (knowledge gained from books lent, skills learned from programs attended). Ultimately, the goal of comparable, more well-known evaluation and assessment initiatives like the Public Library Association’s Project Outcome, Logic Models, or the Institute of Museum and Library Services’ Measures that Matter is to assess the impact—the positive change on patrons’ lives and the community as a whole—that results from library initiatives and services. Library service is constantly evolving. As libraries choose which programs and services they should adopt, it would be helpful to be able to weigh the benefits that the community could expect to receive from each.”
Examples —
A Social Return on Investment (SROI) Toolkit from the University of Exeter is available online.
The Red Rock Public Library, in Red Rock, Ontario, used SROI to describe their library’s impact in a 2024 report.
IFLA, the International Federation of Library Associations, describes the use of ROI internationally by libraries. In this description they include a short discussion of SROI, that is, the evaluation method called Social Return on Investment; more on SROI follows.
The Essex (UK) County Council’s Everyone’s Library Service 2022-2026 Consultation Report, that uses SROI methodologies to better understand the library’s contribution to Essex residents.
SROI is a promising tool for libraries, working alone or with partners, while planning, executing, and then measuring work that benefit their users and their communities.
SROI and Community Partners
Good libraries do good work. Great libraries measure their success by evaluating their positive impact on their users and communities, impacts which often are made possible and magnified by partners with complementary or overlapping missions. In this process libraries frequently multiply both their own and their partners’ effectiveness. The American Library Association (ALA) has featured partnerships in a program called Programming Librarian, a project of ALA’s Public Programming Office. In 2023 they ran a survey that asked libraries “…to describe one partnership that worked well for them… asking…
Who do you consider your public?
What did your partnership focus on?
How did you interact with your partner?
What makes a partnership effective?
What makes partnerships valuable?”
Preliminary results showed that partners were valued in the following areas:
Program design, increasing variety and quality
Program planning, help with finding quality presenters
Program implementation, shared workload and fresh insights
Increasing program impact, improving community outreach and engagement
Capacity building, funding opportunities and staff development
This makes sense. We know, for instance, that libraries’ summer reading programs help shrink students’ ‘summer slide’, that is, the diminution of reading or academic skills experienced by students during the summer. School—library partnerships that address this slide are consistent with both libraries’ and schools’ missions. As a bonus, schools regularly test reading skills. Libraries could piggyback on school’s testing and potentially learn whether their summer reading programs have, in aggregate, improved kids’ reading. Similarly, a library’s and the health department’s goals are both furthered when libraries make an Automated External Defibrillator (AED) or the life-saving opioid antagonist naloxone available in their public spaces.
Partnerships more than repay the work required to building and sustain them. Dr. Gilpin wrote in a October e-mail ”I agree that the partnership role deserves more attention. Libraries can create value by helping other organizations reach people, coordinate services, and accomplish things they could not accomplish as effectively on their own.”
Conclusion
Echoing British Columbia’s McLeod and Montana’s Gilpin, the measure of a library’s value to its community is the positive change it helps bring about in patrons’ lives, and in its community as a whole. These impacts are often best planned, accomplished, and measured through partnering with other community organizations. The SROI planning and evaluation model shows promise of helping you (and your library’s partners) decide where you’re going — and know when you’ve arrived.
____________________________________
Please support Montanans For Libraries’ campaign to provide each Montanan with sufficient, twenty-first century library services.
Bruce Newell is an increasingly retired librarian who lives in Helena. This essay and others like it can be found on the Montanans For Libraries website.